User talk:Satellite5Editor
Welcome![edit]
|
The Signpost: 2 March 2024[edit]
- News and notes: Wikimedia enters US Supreme court hearings as "the dolphin inadvertently caught in the net"
- Recent research: Images on Wikipedia "amplify gender bias"
- In the media: The Scottish Parliament gets involved, a wikirace on live TV, and the Foundation's CTO goes on record
- Obituary: Vami_IV
- Traffic report: Supervalentinefilmbowlday
- WikiCup report: High-scoring WikiCup first round comes to a close
Saying hi from the Teahouse, with an offer of Wiki-Friendship :P[edit]
Hi I'm Chelsea! I read the Teahouse most days, to continue to learn how everything works around here. I'm around the same stage of editing as you: I know how to copyedit, tag things for maintenance, and use talk pages.
I appreciated what you said about getting geared up to learn about sources/citations- I've reviewed all the relevant docs myself, and am pretty familiar with how various citation styles look in Wikicode, but haven't started practicing doing it myself yet. It would be cool to have a casual buddy around here to occasionally check in with on each other's User Talk pages along the learning journey!
To that point, I popped over to the page you had flagged on the Teahouse as needing more eyes- I'm sure more experienced editors than I will have good answers to your overall questions. I went and did further cleanup for the short term, stripping the confusing text down to the most simplistic interpretation available.
While trying to see where this garbled text entered the page, though, I discovered that a user pasted it all in at once a few years back- if you scroll in Edit History down past our recent edits, there was a ~+1425 size addition to the page, from a user who seemed to navigate to the page via the "Suggested Edits- Write a Short Description" tool.
Assuming good faith, the editor was trying to improve the article after finding it through the shortdesc link, but they made a lot of confusing and unsourced changes at once. It looks like the article was a pretty short but straightforward unsourced bio up until that point, so it may become necessary after the community weighs in to revert back and remove the 2 paragraphs you flagged entirely, as they seem to have come from nowhere.
I am on mobile right now, which is a bit unwieldy to comment in places like the Teahouse, but after I leave this direct communication for you, I'll also open a thread on the article's talk page to summarize my concerns and then circle back around from a real computer.
One of the reasons I bothered investigating despite being on my phone was that the chunks of text you found sounded, to me, like they could be copy-pasted from a formal bio on the university's site or elsewhere (albeit then all kind of scrambled up, with sentences pasted over one another). What I discovered makes me *more* concerned about copyvio, so I'll make sure to follow this through and do a proper check on where the heck this article section came from, lol.
Have a great day, nice to "meet" you and hope to touch base soon! Chiselinccc (talk) 21:06, 3 March 2024 (UTC)
- Hello, thank you so much for taking the time to write such a detailed and kind message. It’s definitely only made me more excited to continue contributing to see how helpful and nice everyone around here is. I appreciate your time looking into the issue I raised and look forward to seeing how it plays out. I happily accept your offer and it is nice to meet you as well! Satellite5Editor (talk) 21:52, 3 March 2024 (UTC)
The Signpost: 29 March 2024[edit]
- Technology report: Millions of readers still seeing broken pages as "temporary" disabling of graph extension nears its second year
- Recent research: "Newcomer Homepage" feature mostly fails to boost new editors
- Traffic report: He rules over everything, on the land called planet Dune
- Humour: Letters from the editors
- Comix: Layout issue
The Signpost: 25 April 2024[edit]
- In the media: Censorship and wikiwashing looming over RuWiki, edit wars over San Francisco politics and another wikirace on live TV
- News and notes: A sigh of relief for open access as Italy makes a slight U-turn on their cultural heritage reproduction law
- WikiConference report: WikiConference North America 2023 in Toronto recap
- WikiProject report: WikiProject Newspapers (Not WP:NOTNEWS)
- Recent research: New survey of over 100,000 Wikipedia users
- Traffic report: O.J., cricket and a three body problem
The Signpost: 16 May 2024[edit]
- News and notes: Democracy in action: multiple elections
- Special report: Will the new RfA reform come to the rescue of administrators?
- Arbitration report: Ruined temples for posterity to ponder over – arbitration from '22 to '24
- Comix: Generations
- Traffic report: Crawl out through the fallout, baby