User talk:IEdML

Beer categories question.

Hi. It has been suggested by User:BrianSmithson and supported by User:Syrthiss that the Beer and brewery categories should be renamed. This proposal has been supported and expanded by myself. The notion is that the regional categories should follow the format of "Beer and breweries in Africa" /Europe/Asia/North America/South America/Oceania. "Brewers and breweries" could also be renamed "Beer and breweries by region". And all the countries should also be renamed (and merged if needed) as, for example, "Beer and breweries of Germany", "Beer and breweries of Britain", "Beer and breweries of Poland". The word in each case would be beer rather than beers to allow for general articles on beer culture in each region as well as individual beers.

Comments, suggestions, objections, free beer and simple votes to Wiki Beer Project SilkTork 15:29, 3 April 2006 (UTC)

Nation Building

Hiya, you contributed to the Nation building article a while back. I've just flagged up what I think are a bunch of problems with the article and would welcome your input. Cheers Vizjim 15:11, 16 May 2006 (UTC)

Poll

Hi! Your vote/opinion on brewery notability is requested here: [1] SilkTork 12:28, 20 July 2006 (UTC)

RE: Your comments on Talk:Virb

If you feel a decent, sourced article on Virb can be written that demonstrates how it is notable per WP:WEB, then go ahead and write one in a temp space and I'll unprotect and move it to the mainspace. Every version of the article that has been there up to this point was marketing shite or made no case why this website was in any way notable compared to the millions of other sites out there. There definitely was no critical analysis of Virb vs MySpace, much less one supported by reliable sources. That is why it kept getting deleted.--Isotope23 13:02, 13 April 2007 (UTC)