User:J947/AfD and redirection

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

A consensus to delete, or an AfD having been closed as delete, does not preclude a redirect being made as an alternative to deletion – even by the closer. AfD does not adjudicate the merits of redirects. In general, page history for an AfDed article should stay intact anyway, for us interested non-admins. Redirect it.

Maybe there's a better way to do AfD. Two parts. Firstly, decide, mostly based on GNG, whether a topic deserves its own article. Secondly, if the topic doesn't warrant its own article, discuss what to do with it: merge, redirect, create a list to merge it into, convert into a disambiguation page, and maybe, just rarely, delete.