User:CardinalSims/Matilda

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Matilda submerging Dante in Lethe, as depicted by Gustave Doré.
Matilda submerging Dante in Lethe, as depicted by Gustave Doré.
Matilda collecting flowers in a painting by George Dunlop Leslie. Dante, Virgil, and Statius can be seen in the background.
Matilda collecting flowers in a painting by George Dunlop Leslie. Dante, Virgil, and Statius can be seen in the background.

Matilda, originally spelled Matelda, is a minor character in Dante's Purgatorio, the second canticle of the Divine Comedy. She is present in the final six cantos of the poem, but is unnamed until Canto XXXIII.[1] While Dante makes Matilda's function as a baptizer in the Earthly Paradise clear, commentators have disagreed about what historical figure she is intended to represent, if any.

Role in Purgatorio[edit]

An unfinished painting that depicts Matilda, Dante, Virgil, and Statius in the Earthly Paradise, by John William Waterhouse.
An unfinished painting that depicts Matilda, Dante, Virgil, and Statius in the Earthly Paradise, by John William Waterhouse.[2]

Matilda first appears in Canto XXVIII of Purgatorio. As Dante begins to explore the Earthly Paradise (also known as the Garden of Eden), his movement is stopped by a stream, and he notices a woman collecting flowers and singing on its opposite bank. Taking her to be a woman in love, he asks her to come closer so that he can better hear her song, which reminds him of Prosperina before she was abducted by Hades and "lost springtime" (Purgatorio XXVIII, 48-51). Matilda approaches the water and Dante, who is stricken by her beauty and eager to get closer to her, grows angry at the river that separates them. She identifies Dante as being new to the Earthly Paradise and states that she has answers to any questions he may have. She first explains how the Earthly Paradise is unaffected by the weather on Earth, and that the weather found in the Earthly Paradise is created by the Primum Mobile, the part of Paradise closest to God. Next, she describes the water of the Earthly Paradise, which is divided into two currents: Lethe, which removes the memory of sin from all those who drink from it, and Eunoe, which brings back memories of goods deeds to those who drink from it. Finally, she adds that the Earthly Paradise is the place the ancient poets dreamed about.[1]

In Canto XXIX, Matilda walks south along the bank of the river after singing part of Psalm 32 (Psalm 31 in the Vulgate) to Dante. After the bank curves, the two head east, and Matilda, who refers to Dante as "brother," instructs him to look and listen to what lies ahead: the Church Triumphant. As Dante focuses on the seven candlesticks that lead the procession, Matilda scolds him for not looking at what lies beyond them. Dante heeds her instructions for the rest of the canto and describes the Church Triumphant in great detail.[1]

In Canto XXX, Matilda is present during Beatrice's arrival. Her actions during the scene are not described.[1]

Matilda, though present in the early verses of Canto XXXI, is once again not described until line 91. Dante, who had fainted due to his overwhelming feeling of remorse for his sins, wakes up to find Matilda positioned above him. She orders him to hold onto her and pulls him into Lethe. She then pushes his head under the river, and he drinks from it. Following his purification, Matilda introduces Dante to the four cardinal virtues, Beatrice's handmaidens.[1]

In Canto XXXII, Matilda (alongside Dante and Statius) follows the chariot of the Church Triumphant on its righthand side towards a barren tree, which blooms after the chariot, pulled by a griffin, is bound to it. After Dante falls asleep to the hymn sung by the Church Triumphant, he is awoken by Matilda's voice. Matilda informs Dante that Beatrice is seated under the now-blooming tree after he asks for her whereabouts. While Matilda's actions are not described for the rest of the canto, she is present during the demonstration that Beatrice tells Dante to write down and watches as the chariot is struck by an eagle, visited by a fox (which Beatrice drives back), feathered by an eagle, damaged by a dragon, and feathered again. She continues to watch as a ten-horned figure then emerges from the chariot, followed by a harlot and a giant.[1]

In Canto XXXIII, Matilda is part of the order arranged by Beatrice, along with Dante, Statius, and the seven virtues of the Church Triumphant. They head towards Eunoe, which Dante mistakes for the Tigris and Euphrates. After Dante asks Beatrice for the name of the water, Beatrice finally reveals Matilda's name at line 118; Matilda comments that Lethe's waters would not have caused Dante to forget that he has already been told about Eunoe. At the command of Beatrice, she submerges Dante and Statius in Eunoe, a sensation Dante claims he cannot describe because he has run out of room to write.[1]

Matilda's Function[edit]

Matilda's purpose in the Earthly Paradise is to baptize souls that have finishing purging their sins in Lethe and Eunoe. Although some commentators have suggested that her role as a baptizer is specific to Dante, similar to how the blessed souls present themselves to Dante in the celestial spheres of Paradiso, she commands Statius to follow her to Eunoe in Canto XXXIII, proving that she baptizes all souls before they ascend to Paradise.[1] Matilda has also been compared to a priestess,[3] though it should be noted that the Roman Catholic Church forbids women from being ordained as priests.[4] Commentators have also argued that Matilda, whose sole function is to serve as the purifier of souls in the Earthly Paradise, is a representation of the innocence that can only be regained through a belief in Jesus Christ.[5]

Other commentators have noted that Matilda's earliest appearances draw similarities to the pastorella genre, though the notion of Matilda as a pastorella is quickly subverted. Dante's mistaken belief that Matilda is in love with him and her presence in Canto XXVIII as a beautiful, solitary maiden in the woods have drawn comparison to Guido Cavalcanti's take on the pastorella, "In un boschetto trova' una pasturella."[6] Despite Dante's initial depiction of Matilda, she quickly assumes the role of teacher and sister-in-Christ to Dante (the character) in Canto XXIX,[7] where she scolds him and refers to him as frate, or "brother."[1] Matilda, far from being a romantic interest for Dante, demonstrates the brotherly love found between the blessed souls of Paradise.

Matilda has also been seen as a religious counterpart to Beatrice, representing the "active life" while Beatrice represents the "contemplative life." This representation of the two women is foreshadowed by Dante in Canto XXVII, where he has Dante (the character) dream of the Leah and Rachel, Matilda and Beatrice's biblical counterparts.[1]

Questions Surrounding Matilda's Identity[edit]

There have been many debates surrounding what historical figure Matilda is intended to represent. Popular suggestions for who she is supposed to represent have been Countess Matilda of Tuscany, Saint Matilda, Mechtildis of Hackeborn, and Mechtildis of Magdeburg.[8] The earliest commentators believed that Matilda is Countess Matilda of Tuscany, who supported Pope Gregory VII against Emperor Henry IV and donated numerous territories to the papacy before her death.[9] More recent Dante scholars, such as Charles Hall Grandgent (whose commentary on Dante appears in contemporary editions of the Divine Comedy), also support the idea that Matilda is Countess Matilda of Tuscany.[10] While Countess Matilda of Tuscany is the figure most frequently identified as Dante's Matilda, this selection is not without its flaws. Dante scholar Robert Hollander has identified three issues with the idea that Matilda is is Matilda of Tuscany: she supported the papacy instead of the Holy Roman Emperor, Henry IV; she is typically depicted as a solider rather than as an attractive young woman in historical accounts; and she was a human woman, which would suggest that there was no one to baptize souls before her death in 1115, which is unlikely.[1] Similarly, commentators have objected to Mechtildis of Hackeborn and Mechtildis of Magdeburg as options for Matilda's identity due to Matilda's association with the active life; Mechtildis of Hackeborn is a saint and Mechtildis of Magdeburg was a Christian mystic.[8] Furthermore, Mechtildis of Hackeborn died a mere 2 years before 1300, the year the Divine Comedy takes place, leading scholars to ague that her death was too soon for her to have such a prominent role in the Earthly Paradise.[8]

Modern scholars have also argued that Matilda represents a fictional historical figure within the Divine Comedy that cannot be connected to any actual historical person. In this interpretation of her character, Matilda was the first soul to ascend Mount Purgatory after Christ's Redemption, and is now responsible for baptizing every soul so that it can ascend to Paradise.[5]

While many commentators have attempted to link Matilda to a specific person, others have argued that she is meant to embody a concept instead. Italian literature scholar Mark Musa has suggested that she is exclusively meant to represent the concept of the "active life" described by Dante in Canto XXVII.[11] Because Beatrice refers to Dante to Matilda when he has a question about Eunoe in Canto XXXIII, some scholars have determined that Matilda represents Wisdom itself,[8] a notion that can also be supported by the answers she provides Dante about the Earthly Paradise in Canto XXVIII. However, there are two problems with the idea of Matilda as a symbol: all of Dante's guides have both a historical and a symbolic identity (Virgil, for example, represents the real-life Virgil as well as the concept of Reason), and Matilda's name is not more obviously symbolic, like Malacoda in Inferno.[12] Combining the two schools of thought on Matilda's identity, Italian scholar Victoria Kirkham has argued that Matilda historically represents Countess Matilda of Tuscany and spiritually represents the concept of Wisdom.[12]

References[edit]

  1. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Dante Alighieri (2004). Purgatorio. Jean Hollander, Robert Hollander (1st Anchor books ed ed.). New York: Anchor Books. ISBN 0-385-49700-8. OCLC 54011754. {{cite book}}: |edition= has extra text (help)
  2. ^ "John William Waterhouse, Study for Dante and Matilda". Retrieved 2021-03-26.
  3. ^ "Purgatorio 33 – Digital Dante". digitaldante.columbia.edu. Retrieved 2021-03-28.
  4. ^ "Ordinatio Sacerdotalis (May 22, 1994) | John Paul II". www.vatican.va. Retrieved 2021-03-28.
  5. ^ a b Cervigni, Dino (2008). "Beatrice’s Prophecy, Matilda’s Name, and the Pilgrim’s Renewal" from Lectura Dantis: Purgatorio, A Canto-by-Canto Commentary (1 ed.). University of California Press. doi:10.1525/j.ctt1pn7mj.35. ISBN 978-0-520-25055-0.
  6. ^ "Purgatorio 28 – Digital Dante". digitaldante.columbia.edu. Retrieved 2021-03-28.
  7. ^ "Purgatorio 29 – Digital Dante". digitaldante.columbia.edu. Retrieved 2021-03-28.
  8. ^ a b c d Mazzaro, Jerome (1992). "The Vernal Paradox: Dante's Matelda". Dante Studies, with the Annual Report of the Dante Society (110): 107–120. ISSN 0070-2862.
  9. ^ Glenn, Diana (March 2002). "Matelda in the Terrestrial Paradise" (PDF). Flinders University Languages Group Online Review. 1 – via Flinders University.
  10. ^ Dante Alighieri (1977). The portable Dante. Paolo Milano, Laurence Binyon, Dante Gabriel Rossetti ([Rev. ed.] ed.). New York: Penguin Books. ISBN 0-14-015032-3. OCLC 2963831.
  11. ^ Dante Alighieri (1995). The portable Dante. Mark Musa. New York, N.Y.: Penguin Books. ISBN 0-14-023114-5. OCLC 30319118.
  12. ^ a b Kirkham, Victoria (2008). "Watching Matilda" from Lectura Dantis: Purgatorio, A Canto-by-Canto Commentary (1 ed.). University of California Press. doi:10.1525/j.ctt1pn7mj.30. ISBN 978-0-520-25055-0.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:CardinalSims/Matilda&oldid=1014843717"