Talk:At the Drive-In/Archive 1
 | This page is an archive of past discussions. Do not edit the contents of this page. If you wish to start a new discussion or revive an old one, please do so on the current talk page. |
untitled
Here is an interview, (which may require forum registration) clarifying alot about ATDI. I don't have the writing proficiency to edit the actual article, but this clarifies alot about their past and feelings.
Emo/punk??? I disagree. What's with the tendency to label everything emo nowadays (e.g. Coheed and Cambria)? I'd say punk/prog rock is more appropriate.
I agree that we need to stop labeling everything "emo", but I think that we need to stop labeling bands period. What does Coheed and Cambria have to do with At The Drive-In? The question I would be asking is what's with the tendency to label everything nowadays? I understand that labels can be important sometimes, but nowadays, labels are just meaningless fads that the "emo" kids use to "express" themselves or whatever. I love listening to music, but the labels are becoming more important than the music itself.-Leandreamo
emo
I don't have a beef with the "emo" label. I have a problem with it being applied as a blanket term. Sunny Day Real Estate = emo Dashboard Confessional does not = emo We need to start thinking about the history and geography associated with this term. Also, talking about "waves" of emo would probably be helpful (as in punk or ska). I would call At The Drive-In a "screamo" band. However, labels like this don't really matter, they don't change the music. They just help communities and "scenes" to spring up around new musical enviroments (for better or for worse). Of course, all this is just one persons opinion, and that's all it should be considered as.
I completely agree with what leandremo has said on all the band pages I've visited so far,because we seem to share the same outlook on this(idiotic)labeling thing. Everyone is so caught up in labeling the bands that it seems like no-one really appreciates the music anymore. People are simply just to worried about whether there favorite band is going to be labeled "emo" or not, when they should really be enjoying the music instead of plastering every single band with a label. If I'm correct when you walk into hastings,walmart,bestbuy, or wherever it is you are purchasing you're cds, you dont buy the cd just to label the band do you? I mean you purchase the cd to LISTEN to the MUSIC not LABEL IT!!!!! So next time do us all a favour, and when you buy your next cd appreciate the music instead of labeling it.----Frobot
In an online interview, when confronted with the "emo" label, Omar said something to the effect of "I don't like the label emo, because all music has to be emotional. And to call it emo is not right because all music is emotional"
I've always called them "Post-punk" when referencing them to friends and associates. What comes out today definately isn't punk, and it definately isn't anything close to the integrity of ATDI. Also, I don't think screamo really fits either, because songs like "invalid Litter dept." (aside from the reprise) and "Napoleon Solo" are much softer than your standard Alexisonfire fare. - madProphet
I think it is totally adequate to term it as indie/hard rock/alternative rock, which goes along pretty well that atdi just called themselfs "a rocknroll band" and the fact that they are so totally not emo, and i mean..seriously, totally not emo
I think that they are post-punk/alternative rock, personally... yeah.
I always considered them Post-Hardcore, not only do they sound like Post-Hardcore bands (one or two songs doesn't change the genre) but they were the most influential post-hardcore band.
I agree that they definetly have alot of Post-Punk influence as does a band like thrice. However thrice turns out to be something usualyy very different. Ithink the same goes for ATD-I. A song like Invalid Little Dept., is definetly not very screamo, but most of In\Casino\Out is old school Emo\Screamo at its best. So I think Post Hardcore\Screamo\Indie Rock works.Howl5 21:40, 3 May 2007 (UTC)
Howl5 21:40, 3 May 2007 (UTC)
- I don't agree with screamo at all. I'm glad someone agreed with me and reverted your edit. Please try to reach a consensus before deciding your are right and editing the article. Read the screamo article and very little of what it says matches any of ATD-I. Harmonised guitar? Absent. Breakdowns? COMPLETELY absent. This phrase is also important: "In recent years, the term screamo has been very commonly used to describe emo, post-punk, alternative rock, metalcore, or hardcore bands with emo influences." I think this is what you are doing here. Thanks. Olliemilne 23:16, 3 May 2007 (UTC)
I was reading POST: A Look At The Influence Of Post Hardcore and it does mention several emo bands as their early influences,such as Sunny Day Real Estate,Antioch Arrow and Indian Summer.If you don't have the book you can read it here Pg 269
I wouldn't agree ATDI are emo though.More definite Post-Hardcore/Post-Punk.They may apply to 'post-emo' though. --Nirvanarox55 (talk) 18:29, 5 June 2009 (UTC)
Pink Floyd / Weezer?
Is the Pink Floyd / Weezer comment substantiated by actual statements from members of the band? Musical influences and direction are important issues with a band, and it's easy to make comments like this that are pure speculation or hearsay.
The person who contributed the "comment" writes as though it was/is... But, I don't have the
faintest idea. Also, I think that your second sentence is spot-on. I, personally, would
love to see more citations of sources in wiki-entries concerning bands. ~laonoodlekeemow.
The Guilty Undertaker: I was listening to an interview with Cedric Zavala this afternoon on Sirius, and he stated that the other guys wanted the album to be "sort of like weezer, in that direction, you know?" Just my input.
Why emo?
This is the third band that I've looked up and on every discussion page, everyone is just talking about how emo the band is. How come nobody is talking about At The Drive-In? They were a really good band. I think they deserve better than more emo discussions. Emo is all you will see on the Thursday page too.-Leandreamo
It's not a discussion to talk about how great the band is. It's about how to improve the encyclopedia entry by correctly labeling their genre for those who haven't heard their music before. That's why it's relevent. It's supposed to be educational. This is not a fan forum.141.218.224.193 07:52, 16 June 2006 (UTC)
ATDI are definitively NOT emo, folks ! --92.72.207.209 (talk) 14:18, 31 December 2008 (UTC)
While Relationship of Command is their most popular album, and while it displays more of the alternative and punk side of their post-hardcore base, In/Casino/Out and Acrobatic Tenement are definitely more emo than anything else... regardless of people's desire not to have bands they like lumped in with current '00s pop-punk emo bands. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 68.193.81.107 (talk) 13:32, 13 January 2009 (UTC)
Best band to come out in the 90's to the early 00's
Just as the heading says. This band has to be the most influential band of this decade. Alot of bands try to mimic what they did and how they sounded but they will never be able to lead themselves near or any higher. The great thing about At The Drive-In was their different style of music. It's what we never see anymore. Most bands in the punk genres that come from indie labels sound exactly the same and it's going to destroy our music industry. -RetroHippie
I agree completely. At The Drive-In has a very unique sound and it is impossible for other bands to imitate what they were able to do.It was great bands like At The Drive-In that worked hard and developed great music, and that's what we need to see more of nowadays. I would actually prefer At The Drive-In over The Mars Volta, but I like what those guys have done with the music as well. We need to start hearing some bands with a unique sound and not all this shit that just sounds the same. So I say good job to At The Drive-In.-Leandreamo
Wouldn't you agree though that many of today's bands have copied elements of the ATDI sound? I mean, chop and edit Relationship of Command a littole and you can find all kinds of riffs and tricks that are all over today's rock scene (yes, even emo). I bet you'll hear prog echoes of ADTI all over for years to come.SteelyDave 16:35, 30 March 2006 (UTC)
"extremely poetic"
extreme poeticism could be the name of a mockumentary about a similar but much more humorous, and more fictitious, band.
"Acrobatic Tenement, which, although undoubtedly a hardcore punk album, lacked the energy seen in later works." Citation? As far as I can tell Acrobatic Tenement sounds more energetic and ferocious than their later works.
Agreed, I don't exactly understand why that was written there. - Retro Hippie
Band Name Origination
The author who wrote this article states that At the Drive-In got its name from the Poison song "Talk Dirty to Me" and the song "At the Movies" by the Bad Brains. I have a problem with this in that I just don't think it's true.
First, while that Poison song does have the lyric, "At the drive-in . . ." I'd like some documented evidence (an interview, etc.) that the band pulled their name from this song lyric. Just because some song lyric contains the phrase, "At the drive-in" doesn't mean that the band took their name from it.
The reason why this disturbs me is because I think Poison sucks and I don't think At the Drive-In would borrow their name from a peurile song like "Talk Dirty to Me." Admittedly, this is my personal opinion, but I also think that the author was speculating about the origination of the band's name.
Second, why does the author mention two song names? It's either one or the other or neither, no? Unless the author provides a citation for the reference then I'm going to omit that portion of the article in a few days.
Aside from the sentence I've been addressing, the rest of the article is great and I really appreciate that someone took the time to cull the information to write it. However, again, I don't think that part should be included unless the author can document his/her source.
-Justin
---I too, have read the interview where they stated that they got the name from a Poison song, but I forget where the interview is at. After they mentioned that they got it from a Poison song, they laughed, meaning that it was probably pretty ridiculous to them, lol. :] -Retro Hippie
Yeah, I had read this interview aswell. They stated they did it because everyone in El Paso was into Hair Metal at the time and if they ever wanted to make it they had to identify with it.
would it have anything to do with two of their early songs,'ludvico drive-in' and 'communication
drive-in'? —Preceding unsigned comment added by Nirvanarox55 (talk • contribs) 11:05, 7 February 2009 (UTC)
The Eagle Has Landed
A while ago, I added under the cimpilation heading, "The Eagle has Landed." I wasn't surprised to see it taken off shortly there after. I just want to clarify, and hopefully somebody can come up with the proper documentation. At The Drive-In's "Salient" was featured on this compilation, which is a mix of distant instrument tracks with Cedric performming some spoken word--which includes many lyrics from At The Drive-in songs--over it. It is VERY hard to track down this album, so it seems. I saw it on Ebay years ago, and it took me many years to find the track "Salient" on any p2p program. I believe there is a discussion of the song/album on the mars volta fan site, the comatorium. If anybody could find information regarding this album, to post under the discography, it would be great, because a lot of fans don't seem to know about it.Shokknterror 03:56, 16 November 2006 (UTC)
- I personally don't trust ebay for my discog info, but if you can find a thread on the coma maybe it is real. Zopwx2 04:47, 16 November 2006 (UTC)
Oh, I know the song you are mentioning. A friend of mine got it off Limewire a few months ago. I don't remember there being any lyrics on it, but I guess there were. - Retro Hippie
there was also a previously unreleased atd-i song that came out on a rocksound cover compilation a few years ago, it's also worth mentioning that the Nakia side project isn't mentioned here at all, which it should be, don't know too much info myself, it was the drummer who was involved. E Ghost 17:37, 29 April 2007 (UTC)
Yes, this comp does feature an ATDI song. Released on Tranquility Base Records, and wrapped in one of two map designs, ours is of West Virgina/PA. There's a lot that could be added here, like the "Don't Be Scared" comps on Fearless. Or the live album on yellow vinyl from Lost Horse Records (even though I've never seen any other evidence of the label besides this 'vinyl bootleg' as it's called. What do you all think, where is the most appropriate place to list the ENTIRETY of everything ever from them? I, for one, would find information regarding all the various versions of their albums to be extremely helpful. Like the difference between Alfaro Vive Carajo as released on Offtime Records in Chicago, and the version on Western Breed that's all hand-done and includes some refs to Sarah and Laura. Strikew3st (talk) 06:32, 12 November 2008 (UTC)
Fair use rationale for Image:At The Drive In.jpg
Image:At The Drive In.jpg is being used on this article. I notice the image page specifies that the image is being used under fair use but there is no explanation or rationale as to why its use in Wikipedia articles constitutes fair use. In addition to the boilerplate fair use template, you must also write out on the image description page a specific explanation or rationale for why using this image in each article is consistent with fair use.
Please go to the image description page and edit it to include a fair use rationale. Using one of the templates at Wikipedia:Fair use rationale guideline is an easy way to insure that your image is in compliance with Wikipedia policy, but remember that you must complete the template. Do not simply insert a blank template on an image page.
If there is other other fair use media, consider checking that you have specified the fair use rationale on the other images used on this page. Note that any fair use images uploaded after 4 May, 2006, and lacking such an explanation will be deleted one week after they have been uploaded, as described on criteria for speedy deletion. If you have any questions please ask them at the Media copyright questions page. Thank you.BetacommandBot 22:33, 31 May 2007 (UTC)
Shit needs a rewrite
This is awful sounds like some from the comatorium wrote some fan fic Cracksells (talk) 02:39, 22 March 2008 (UTC)
Wikipedia is not a democracy
I see debates about whether or not At The Drive-In's music was emo or not. Wikipedia is not about personal interpretations of editors, or whether you "think" or "don't think" they were emo. Allmusic is in the top tier of reliable sources for music articles; if it is sourced from Allmusic, the debate is over. Additionally, I see many editors' contemporary POV of what emo is today—not to mention the adolescent social stigma surrounding the term—unduly influencing this band's genre edits. --Tim010987 (talk) 12:35, 15 December 2008 (UTC)
- Allmusic is not a reliable source for defining musical styles. Unless there is a consensus, a genre should not be added to a band's Infobox. As it is, I can't find too many sources defining At the Drive-In as emo. (Ibaranoff24 (talk) 07:24, 15 January 2009 (UTC))
Citation needed: founded!
Hi all, sorry for my english. :) In the first paragraph "History" of ATDI, there is this sentence by Cedric: "I'm not the only guy [...] doesn't mean they're not important." and then the citation needed form. Now I found the citation, it comes from the live at Big Day Out of 2001, Cedric says this during a break between two songs. It's true, I just listened to it, you can also verify watching the video (even available on p2p I suppose) of ATDI at 2001 Big Day Out. But I don't know how to remove the citation needed form and dom't know how to report the citation. So please someone of you do this, I can't. :) -Carminuz
Could someone please post a source for the band being active "2009-present"
I got really excited when I saw "2009-present" and would really like someone to post an article stating the band is back together. If not please remove it; many people all over the world are waiting for ATDI to reunite and it's wrong to string them along like that. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 72.13.255.194 (talk) 04:56, 30 March 2009 (UTC)
Angels and Airwaves Bit
I removed the following from the "Breakup" section. It sounds like gossip and there is no source.
Originally, Bixler was recruited by Angels & Airwaves frontman Tom Delonge to be the lead vocalist for his new project. Although "AvA" proved to be a space rock group as Bixler was looking for, he declined stating "I'm here to play the type of music I want and not sell out...I'd never play with a talentless prick who has writers in Hollywood write his songs. He's an inferior muscian."
If you find a source feel free to repost this Eggness (talk) 09:20, 13 April 2009 (UTC)
Post-grunge?
By my personal concept, I don't consider it, but, does anyone believes that ATD-I qualifies as post-grunge?. 190.28.179.252 (talk) 04:31, 4 June 2009 (UTC)