Amagasaki Serial Murder Incident

The Amagasaki Serial Murder Incident (尼崎連続殺人事件) was a 2012 several serial murder and body dumping case, in which family households in Japan were tortured continuously for more than 25 years.^{[clarification needed]} The crimes began with the disappearance of a woman in or around 1987. At least 8 victims were confirmed to have died, mainly as a result of assault, confinement and other forms of abuse.^[1] The crimes were committed mainly in Amagasaki, but also in six other prefectures, Hyogo, Kochi, Kagawa, Okayama, Shiga and Kyoto.^[2]

The incident was discovered when the suspects Miyoko Sumida (角田美代子) and Masanori Sumida (角田正則) were arrested in November 2011. The cousin of the ringleader received a life sentence over the Amagasaki murders.

Overview[edit]

For at least 25 years, the woman believed to be the main suspect of this case had been living together with many others in the southeastern area of Amagasaki City, Hyogo Prefecture, building a pseudo-family not related to her by blood.^[3] Although several suspicious deaths and disappearances had occurred one after another around 1987, starting with the disappearance of Woman A, the case would not come to light for many years.

However, in November 2011, a woman in her 40s who had been held captive escaped from confinement and ran to the police. Sumida was arrested on suspicion of assaulting Kazuko Oe's eldest daughter following her death. Furthermore, this case allowed for the investigation to further advance, and a series of other incidents came to light when an accessory from a separate case, who had been arrested in October 2012 (the theft of C’s mother’s pension), fully confessed to the crime. Shortly after, in December 2012, Sumida committed suicide at the detention center of the Hyogo Prefectural Police Department without saying much about the incident.

A joint investigation by the Hyogo, Kagawa, and Okinawa prefectural police, which had been investigating the cases based on the statements of X's accomplices, was disbanded in March 2014, which effectively ended the investigation. Eleven people, including X and her relatives, were indicted on charges of manslaughter and murder for six of the eight confirmed deaths. Trials were held for only ten of the relatives as X had committed suicide in jail. The whereabouts of three people who were close to X are still unknown. One was allegedly killed by X but the body was never found, and the other two are missing but their information was made available to the public ^{[citation needed]}.

Among the numerous mass murder cases in Japan, one notable feature of this particular incident is the high number of individuals arrested and referred to prosecutors, totaling 17. It was later revealed that during the "family hijacking", Sumida would take advantage of minor weaknesses and intimidation tactics to control entire families. It was also revealed that many of the victims were subjected to forced violence against their relatives, were restricted from eating, drinking, and sleeping, and were even deprived of their property and forced to break apart their families. Many of the arrested and documented persons who were taken in by X as members of her pseudo-family were also forced to be involved in the crimes. In addition, many of these members ended up becoming relatives either through forced marriages or adoption ^{[citation needed]}.

Persons Involved in Incident[edit]

（List of those who were arrested, prosecuted, deceased, or claimed as a missing person.）

Main Culprit X (Arrest & Death)[edit]

Born in 1948.^[4]

On December 12, 2012, she committed suicide in a detention center at the Hyogo Prefectural Police Headquarters. She held absolute power within her pseudo-family, forcing her cohabitants to swear their loyalty and sanctioning those who disobeyed her. She would also take them on trips and outings. Some would take this opportunity to escape but would be persistently sought out and brought back.^[4]

She was charged with one account of manslaughter, but the charges were dismissed due to the nature of the death. However, following her death, she was charged for the manslaughter and murders of her eldest son, second son, and eldest daughter among other charges.^[4]

X一"Family"[edit]

A "family" formed through repeated adoptions with relatives in the course of X's multiple "family takeovers", none of whom are related by blood.

X's Sister-in-Law H (A's oldest son's registered wife) 【Arrested】: Born in 1953.^[4]; They had known each other since childhood since H's mother had been renting a room from X's mother, where they had lived together for several decades.^[5] She was adopted by X's mother in 1988.; According to H's own testimony, X would often yell at H's parents and forcibly separated her form her family, at which point the two began to live together. H was then forced to work at snack bars and a "soap-land" as a prostitute by X, and most of her salary was taken away by X. It is also said that she had attempted to commit suicide due to the debt she had incurred in her life and the pressure of her pseudo-family.; In 2001, on X's orders, she married A's eldest son. It's said that she played a role similar to X's treasurer and was the first to confess the disposal location of the three bodies linked to the series of incidents. She kept a diary detailing communal life, in which no incidents of violence or abuse were recorded, but it was noted that the victims' names ceased to appear around the time of their deaths. [clarification needed]; In the case regarding the theft of the pensions of eldest son and mother of Family C, H was sentenced to two years in prison at the first trial. She was then indicted for murder and other crimes against the eldest and second son of family A and the eldest daughter of family D, and received a sentence of 21 years in prison ^{[citation needed]}.
X's Common-Law Husband I 【Arrested】: Born in 1950.^[4]; He had known X since he was in his twenties ^[4]and had a long, common-law relationship with her, but it was reportedly a subservient relationship as he claims that she was abusive at times. He was indicted for murder and other crimes against the eldest son A, the second son A, and the eldest daughter D, two of which were found guilty of murder and one of which was found guilty of inflicting bodily injury, and sentenced to 21 years in prison ^{[citation needed]}.
X's Female Cohabitant 【Deceased】: Born 1941.^[4]; It is said that they got to know each other through her relationship with X's brother. They lived together as if in a domestic partnership and became joint debtors when they purchased a condominium together in 2000. She allegedly died around November 2008, and seven people have been charged with confinement. ^{[citation needed]}
X's Registered Son J (N's Husband) 【Arrested】: Born in 1986.^[4]
The Third Son of B's Fourth Son M (X's eldest son-in-law) 【Arrested】: Born in 1982.
X's Male Step Cousin K (C's ex-wife's stepchild) 【Arrested】: Born in 1974.^[6]
D's Second Daughter N (J's wife) 【Arrested】: Born in 1985.
X's Male Cohabitant L (Husband of D's eldest daughter) 【Arrested】: Born in 1969.

A's Relatives[edit]

A and her three children once lived in a rented room in her parent's home. By the mid 1980s, the family of four began to live together.

A【Missing】: Born between 1927- 1928.
A's Eldest Son (H's husband)【Deceased】: Born in 1953.
A's Second Son【Deceased】: Born in 1958.

B Family[edit]

Around March 1998, X became involved in a dispute over the funeral of B's aunt and demanded money from her relatives.

B【Deceased】: Born between 1925 - 1926.
B's Eldest Son【Deceased】: Born between 1974 - 1975.
B's Fourth Son【Missing】: Born between 1975 - 1976.

C & D Family[edit]

C's Mother【Deceased】: Born in 1924.
C【info from Document Submitted to Prosecution】: Born between 1942 - 1943.
C's Brother【Deceased - info from Document Submitted to Prosecution】: Born between 1948 - 1949.
C's Sister（Second Daughter）【Missing - info from Document Submitted to Prosecution】: Born between 1952 - 1953.
C's Grandchild【info from Document Submitted to Prosecution】: Born between 1980 - 1981.; A case was referred to the public prosecutor's office on suspicion of causing death by bodily injury to C's mother; however the case was dropped due to the expiration of the statute of limitations.
D（C's mother's eldest daughter）【Deceased - info from Document Submitted to Prosecution】: Born in 1949.
D's Eldest Daughter（Wife of L）【Deceased - info from Document Submitted to Prosecution】: Born in 1982.
D's Brother-in-Law【Deceased】: Born in 1944.

E & F Family[edit]

E, who had been working for a private railway company at the time, responded to a complaint which led X to intervene in the family affairs of E's family and E's mother-in-law (F).

Progression of the Case[edit]

Family A moves in with X[edit]

A: Disappearance Case（ca. 1987）[edit]

B Family Hijacking Case（March 1998- January 2000)[edit]

Death of B[edit]

B's Eldest Son Falls to Death[edit]

X and Others are Arrested for Theft[edit]

C & D Family Hijacking Case（ca. 2002- October, 2003）[edit]

Death of C's Mother -- Abandonment of Body[edit]

Heading Back to Takamatsu[edit]

Death of D's Ex-Husband's Brother[edit]

Murder of Family A's Eldest Son & Insurance Fraud Case (Prosecution Case)[edit]

D: Abduction Case (Prosecution Case)[edit]

D: Manslaughter Case（Prosecution Case）[edit]

Death of D Family's Eldest Daughter -- Abandonment of Body（Prosecution Case）[edit]

Female G's Confinement & Death（November 2008）（Prosecution Case)[edit]

E & F Family Hijacking Case（April 2009 - November 2011）[edit]

Death of the Second Son of the A Family -- Abandonment of Body（July 2011）（Prosecution Case）[edit]

Death of F's Mother -- Abandonment of Body（September 11, 2011）（Prosecution Case）[edit]

F's Eldest Daughter Escapes -- X and Others Arrested[edit]

After X's Arrest[edit]

On November 7, 2011, Hyogo Prefectural Police found a drum can containing F's body in a rental house in Amagasaki City, and on November 26, 2011, X and others were arrested on suspicion of abandoning F's body ^{[citation needed]}. After hearing about this report, D's husband rushed to the Kobe District Public Prosecutors Office's Amagasaki branch and explained the incident to the police ^{[citation needed]}.

In August 2012, investigators from the Hyogo Prefectural Police found C hiding out in Amagasaki City under a false name. Based on C's testimony, H and N were re-arrested on charges of theft for withdrawing C and C's mother's pension without permission. During the interrogation of this re-arrest, H confessed to the murder and dumping of the body in September, and N also acknowledged H's confession ^{[citation needed]}.

In October, the bodies of D's eldest daughter, D's brother-in-law, and G were discovered underneath the floorboards of C's mother's house in Amagasaki City. On December 3, the body of C's mother was discovered in a farm equipment shed in Takamatsu City, and on December 5. X and seven others were re-arrested on suspicion for the confinement and murder of A's second son. On December 30, the body of A's second son was found in the sea in Okayama Prefecture ^{[citation needed]}.

December 12: X commits suicide inside Hyogo Prefectural Police Headquarters.

February 4, 2013: K, I, and seven others arrested on suspicion of confining and murdering D's eldest daughter ^{[citation needed]}.

March 6: K, I, and seven others re-arrested on suspicion of the confinement and manslaughter of G ^{[citation needed]}.

May 21: K, I, and six others re-arrested for the murder of A's eldest son^{[citation needed]}. June 26: H, K, and six others re-arrested on suspicion of committing insurance fraud on A's eldest son ^{[citation needed]}. September 25: K and seven others arrested on suspicion of manslaughter of D ^{[citation needed]}.

Aftermath[edit]

On the 12th of December 2012, Miyoko Sumida committed suicide in a holding cell, whilst on suicide watch.

Since October 12, when a series of incidents were uncovered, Sumida had made several statements to her lawyers and police officers in charge of her detention alluding to suicidal ideation, saying things such as, "There is no point in living," "I want to die. How can I die?" The death of the main suspect following arrest made it difficult for investigators to uncover the truth of the case. ^{[citation needed]}.

On December 19, X's body was cremated in Kobe City but no relatives came to claim the remains ^{[citation needed]}.

References[edit]

^ 家族呪縛、25年の闇尼崎の連続変死事件. Asahi Shimbun (in Japanese). 2012-10-18.
^ "尼崎遺棄事件被害者 1日に水500ml、トイレ2回の監禁生活". Josei Seven (女性セブン) (in Japanese). 2012-11-01. Archived from the original on 2014-02-01. Retrieved 2013-04-14 – via 東京産業新聞社.
^ "Victims found at Amagasaki house were imprisoned on apartment balcony before death". Japan Today. 2012-10-29. Retrieved 2024-04-16.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f ^g ^h "平成２７年１１月１３日宣告平成２４年（わ）第８８７号，第９８６号，平成２５年（わ）第１２０号，第２１１号，第４３９号，第５７３号，第８２７号死体遺棄，逮捕監禁，殺人，監禁，詐欺，生命身体加害略取，傷害致死被告事件" (PDF) (in Japanese). 2011-11-09.
^ "（主犯女X）ら逮捕　擬似家族の闇を解明へ". 読売新聞 (in Japanese). 2012-11-07. Archived from the original on 2012-11-11.
^ "「（主犯女X）元被告に次ぐ責任」１０罪、義理のいとこ○○被告に無期判決　神戸地裁". 産経新聞 (in Japanese). 2015-11-13. pp. 1/2. Retrieved 2017-03-17.